| 1891 - Nathan Lewis Guthrie |
1892 - James William Baker |
| 1893 - Edgar A. Nichols |
1894 - William F. Nichols PGM |
| 1895 - William F. Nichols PGM |
1896 - William F. Nichols PGM |
| 1897 - Edgar A. Nichols |
1898 - Edgar A. Nichols |
| 1899 - Edgar A. Nichols |
1900 - Mariano J. Soto |
| 1901 - Kasper Hauser |
1902 - Kasper Hauser |
| 1903 - Henry Alfred Morgan PGM |
1904 - Henry Alfred Morgan PGM |
| 1905 - Mariano J. Soto |
1906 - William A. Fiege |
| 1907 - John N. Lean |
1908 - Kasper Hauser |
| 1909 - Kasper Hauser |
1910 - Kasper Hauser |
| 1911 - Benjamin J. McKinney |
1912 - John C. Wilson |
| 1913 - Joseph W. Angle |
1914 - Harvey L. McCoy |
| 1915 - Alphonso B. Marchman |
1916 - Lem Wallace |
| 1917 - John C. Wilson |
1918 - Joseph Frank Wootan |
| 1919 - Frank W. Rottman |
1920 - John C. Gung'l |
| 1921 - Frank W. Rottman |
1922 - John C. Wilson |
| 1923 - Martin W. Bouck |
1924 - John P. Cummings |
| 1925 - Marshall J. Nicholson |
1926 - Marshall J. Nicholson |
| 1927 - John N. Brookbank |
1928 - Charles A. Smith |
| 1929 - Edward B. McAleb |
1930 - Charles E. Reno |
| 1931 - Virgil E. Swanner |
1932 - Lawrence J. Fulmer |
| 1933 - Walter T. Linam |
1934 - Martin Gentry |
| 1935 - John P. Cummings |
1936 - Elbert B. Moss |
| 1937 - Edward B. McAleb |
1938 - Edwin I. Tout |
| 1939 - Dana T. Milner |
1940 - Rufus R. Nelson |
| 1941 - Dana T. Milner |
1942 - Wallace E. Lundquist |
| 1943 - Thomas J. Higgins |
1944 - Ben D. White |
| 1945 - George V. Grosh |
1946 - Mike M. Bennett |
| 1947 - Robert R. Giles |
1948 - Jess T. LaPrade |
| 1949 - Boyd Porter Fox |
1950 - Carlton P. Gordon |
| 1951 - Carlton P. Gordon |
1952 - Leonard G. Rottman |
| 1953 - David L. Crismon |
1954 - Malcolm M. Giles |
| 1955 - Lester F. Bethel |
1956 - T. Haynes Moore |
| 1957 - Malcolm M. Giles |
1958 - Lynn Camp |
| 1959 - Vernon Spurgeon |
1960 - Allan O. Ringnell |
| 1961 - Milon G. Miskovich |
1962 - Robert B. Larned |
| 1963 - Theodor Teimer Jr |
1964 - Daniel G. Anderson |
| 1965 - Carmey G. Page |
1966 - Lyman M. Jensen |
| 1967 - Elrid B. Howard |
1968 - Floyd R. Bethel |
| 1969 - Howard Bethel |
1970 - Robert Ward |
| 1971 - Lester F. Bethel Jr |
1972 - Emile Casteel |
| 1973 - Lloyd E. Swanson |
1974 - Don K. Briggs |
| 1975 - Ralph B. Merrick |
1976 - Lee A. Jernigan |
| 1977 - Robert W. Spinney |
1978 - Robert W. Spinney |
| 1979 - Dale Hinkson |
1980 - Robert Ward |
| 1981 - Ralph B. Merrick |
1982 - Luther E. Kennedy |
| 1983 - Wesley J. Moore |
1984 - Adam L. Elrod |
| 1985 - Marlin S. Easthouse |
1986 - Robert Ward |
| 1987 - Robert W. Spinney |
1988 - Marlin S. Easthouse |
| 1989 - Paul W. Lee |
1990 - Michael S. Havens |
| 1991 - Robert E. Coder |
1992 - Donald R. Crossman |
| 1993 - Alexander Bollman |
1994 - Steve Seplak |
| 1995 - Joe Hall |
1996 - Gerald Muir |
| 1997 - Don K. Briggs |
1998 - Clint Cohorn |
| 1999 - Gerald Muir |
2000 - Marlin S. Easthouse |
| 2001 - Marlin S. Easthouse |
2002 - Kelley Rowden |
| 2003 - Kelley Rowden |
2004 - Craig Wilkins |
| 2005 - Richard Prina |
2006 - Kelley Rowden |
| 2007 - Marlin S. Easthouse |
2008 - Marlin S. Easthouse |
| 2009 - Marlin S. Easthouse |
2010 - Marlin S. Easthouse |
